Wrap Battle Wrap Up!

Wrap Battle
McCalls 6884 | Burda 6829 | New Look 6301 | McCalls 7504

In my Wrap Battle McCalls 6884, Burda 6829, New Look 6301 and McCalls 7504 went head to head. If I were to rank the entries it would be in this order:

  1. Burda 6829
  2. New Look  6301
  3. McCalls 6884
  4. McCalls 7504

Burda is the hands down winner though I do love NL6301 it is a real-faux wrap dress after.The Burda is also a quicker sew since it has less pieces.

The two McCalls patterns were close. 7504 allows for a better fit, but I hate lining while M6884 lacks fit, but it much simpler to sew. Though my issues with M7504 can be fixed if I were to rate them “striaght out the envelope” M6884 wins.

Here’s my likes and dislikes of each:

McCalls 6884


  • Minimal pieces
  • Sleeve & length options
  • Side tie positioning
McCalls 7504


  • Pleated sides
  • Tulip hem
  • Waist seam
  • Lining
New Look 6301


  • Pleated wrap bodice
  • Pleated skirt
  • Neck & arm bands finish
  • Skirt & sleeve options
  • Side tie placement
  • Elastic casing at waist (I omitted them)
Burda 6829


  • Tulip hem
  • Side gathers
  • Sleeve options
  • Minimal pattern pieces
  • Facings (I omitted them)
How would you rank the four dresses? Did you enjoy this “series”? What other categories should I compare?

13 responses to “Wrap Battle Wrap Up!”

  1. I loved this series! My favorite is the Burda, which is a bit annoying to me as I own the other three patterns! Ah well, another addition to my pattern stash!


  2. Oh wow! I just found myself reading all your “wrap battle” posts. They were pretty fun reads and the like/dislike table in this post was actually pretty helpful. Thank you!


  3. What a great idea! I have a suggestion to make this page more user friendly – captions on your photos and drawings, so we know which one is which when looking at the summary table.


What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: